Malcolm Dorfman Seminar
Sensei Hyder organized a seminar last Saturday 19th September 2009 at Hilton Garden Inn led by Sensei Malcolm Dorfman 8th Dan of the Karatenomichi World Federation South Africa. Sensei Dorfman was accompanied by his South African Elite Team trio, Nick, Kevin and Nick enroute to international competitions.
Sensei Dorfman took time to explain that in his short time he would like to give us some ideas to think about, supplementing not contradicting our individual teachers. Ideas accumulated from a lifetime of training and a lot time with Japanese Shotokan Masters.
The training was practical with each idea being explained and demonstrated then practiced: mistakes being highlighted and corrected.
Some questions posed were, “What is an effective technique?” What works for you? Why train a technique if it is not effective? As an example after a minutes light free sparing the question was posed was why oi-tsuke (front stepping punch) was not used. This was then discussed and an effective technique demonstrated along with footwork. The foot work from a fighting stance always pointed forward with the hip pulled back, torsioned to release into action. Groin protected at all times with the rear leg compressed ready to push off.
For me one of the most important ideas discussed was “dead feet.” For any technique the question asked was “How did the back foot contribute to that technique into become the most effective that it could be?” A foot pointing 90 degrees away was not contributing at all compared to one pointing in the direction of motion: like a sprinter off the starting blocks.
We did Jion kata once then repeated it stepping through considering the contribution of the back foot for each technique. Each move was broken down to part movements and the leg dynamics explained. Particular emphasis on weigh shifting, compression, hip rotation and alignment of the back foot prior to exploding into the technique. These same concepts were repeated with the second session using heian shodan.
Common themes for the day were “what is an effective technique?”, “does it work?” and “if it does not work, why does it not work?” this was followed by examples of how to make it work.
During the second session we went though Kihon basics, with emphasis on contraction and expansion, relaxing and tension. Relaxed enough to whip into position without forcing or pushing using the correct effective technique. Mae geri, front kick starts with the heel hitting your bum and flicking out with the knee rising before snapping back. No pushing of hips and totally relaxed. If the foot slides up the target you are not focusing the ball of your foot. This was the start of some telling examples and paired training.
A drill on getting to the target built on the earlier sessions hip tension and release to propel forward to make distance. This was tried with stepping punch and front kick.
Sensei Dorfman is very passionate about karate and enthusiastic about teaching. He described karate as “95% passion 5% technique, anything else is might as well be aerobics.” Some of the other quotations were “One blow, one person down.”
“Use effective techniques, why would you use anything else.” “You cannot hide in Heian Shodan, which is why it is used in 7th Dan exam.” “Do not confuse a pose (the end position) with an effective technique.” “Kihon is Kihon, kata is Kihon, kumite is kihon. (basic techniques are fundamental and should be consistent throughout forms and sparing)” “Winning competitions is fun, and I enjoyed it, but there has to be more to it than that: there is otherwise I wouldn’t be still training.”
Nick, Kevin and Nick respectfully assisted in the seminars and were willing participants in demonstrating and being demonstrated on. They really enjoy karate and the challenges of competition. Keeping in mind that they are not sponsored and they have to work hard to raise funds to get to these international competitions all of which are quite a distance from South Africa. I’m sure they get a lot out of it in return. A long time ago I worked in South Africa and it is good to such great and capable ambassadors out internationally.
Sensei Dorfman succeed in sharing a lot in a very short time. To me it could be summarized as to think about what is right for you to produce a single effective technique each and every move. This reminded me that these are all concepts we are told day in day out by our Sensei.
My thanks to Sensei Hyder for organizing the event, also my apologies for not being able to stay to watch the competition that followed. And my special thanks to Sensei Dorfman for his time and insight.
OSS - Julian Fisher
